Scaling Your Finance Department: When to Outsource vs. Hire In-House at Each Growth Stage

As your company grows, so do its financial complexities. The simple spreadsheet that worked for your first few customers quickly becomes inadequate. Deciding when to bring finance functions in-house versus relying on external experts is a critical strategic decision that impacts your cost, efficiency, and control. Here’s a breakdown of the optimal model for each stage of growth.

Pre-Seed/Seed Stage (0–$1M Revenue)

At this early stage, cash is king, and founder time is the most valuable resource. The focus should be on product and market fit, not bookkeeping.

• The Model: Rely on outsourced bookkeeping and tax support to ensure compliance and clean records from the start.
• Founder's Role: Founders should maintain ownership of day-to-day cash management and key performance indicators (KPIs). Schedule quarterly check-ins with a financial advisor to review performance and plan ahead.

Early Growth Stage ($1–$5M Revenue)

As revenue and transaction volume increase, the need for more structure becomes apparent. It's time to move from annual reporting to a more frequent, disciplined financial cadence.

• The Model: Introduce a monthly close discipline. This can be managed by adding a part-time or fractional controller. To handle the growing number of invoices and payments efficiently without hiring full-time staff, continue to outsource AP/AR and payroll.

Scaling Stage ($5–$20M Revenue)

At this level, finance becomes a strategic partner in the business. You need dedicated internal expertise to manage operations and support strategic planning.

• The Model: Hire your first full-time in-house senior accountant or controller to own the day-to-day financial operations. For high-level strategy, engage a fractional CFO to handle financial forecasting, board reporting, and fundraising support.

Expansion Stage ($20M+ Revenue)

With significant scale, the finance function must evolve to support complex operations and forward-looking analysis.

• The Model: It's time to build out internal FP&A (Financial Planning & Analysis) and compliance capabilities. Many companies at this stage adopt a highly effective hybrid model: an in-house strategic finance team supported by outsourced shared services for high-volume, transactional work.

Key Triggers for Your Decision

Triggers for Hiring In-House

Certain operational complexities are strong signals that you need dedicated, internal staff.

• Complex Operations: If your business involves complex revenue recognition (e.g., multi-year SaaS contracts), intricate inventory management, or operates across multiple legal entities or international markets.
• Heavy Compliance: If you face frequent audits or stringent regulatory compliance demands, having an in-house team that deeply understands your business is essential for managing risk.

Triggers for Outsourcing

Outsourcing remains the best choice when flexibility and specialized skills are the priority.

• Need for Agility: If you need specialized talent on demand (e.g., for a specific project or technical accounting issue) without the commitment of a full-time hire.
• Process Efficiency: If your primary goal is to compress your month-end close cycle or implement automation without a large upfront investment in technology and training.

Cost & ROI Considerations

The decision isn't just about capability; it's about cost-effectiveness. Conduct a thorough analysis comparing the fully loaded salary of an in-house employee (including benefits, taxes, and overhead) versus the subscription fee for an outsourced service. Remember to factor in the intangible ROI: the value of process maturity, reduced errors, and the ability to make faster, data-driven decisions.

Find Your Ideal Finance Model

Not sure what you need at your current stage? We’ll assess your gaps and design a hybrid model—outsourcing where it saves money and hiring in-house where it adds control and strategic value.

‍