Accrual vs Cash Accounting for Real Estate (2025)

Cash vs. Accrual: Two Ways to Tell Your Real Estate Story

When you track income and expenses for rental or real estate-related businesses, you have a fundamental choice: record activity when money changes hands (cash basis) or when it is earned or incurred (accrual basis). Both methods are legitimate; they just answer slightly different questions.

Understanding the trade-offs helps you decide which method gives you information that matches how you actually run the business.

How Cash Basis Accounting Works

Under the cash method:

• You record rental income when the payment hits your account.
• You record expenses when you pay the bill.

This approach often feels intuitive because it mirrors bank activity. If your main concern is "Do we have enough cash to cover upcoming obligations?" cash-basis reports show that directly.

For many small landlords and simple rental operations, cash basis keeps bookkeeping straightforward and aligns reasonably well with how decisions are made day to day.

How Accrual Accounting Works

Accrual accounting, by contrast, focuses on when income is earned and when obligations arise:

• Rent is recognized when it is due, even if a tenant pays a few days later.
• Expenses are recorded when you receive goods or services, not just when you pay the invoice.

This method produces financial statements that reflect performance over a period, independent of exact payment timing. It can be especially useful when you manage multiple properties, work with vendors on terms, or want to match expenses to the periods they support.

Tax Implications and Requirements

For tax purposes, many smaller rental activities are allowed to use cash basis, subject to certain revenue thresholds and conditions. Larger operations or those engaged in particular types of activities may be required to use accrual methods.

Switching from one method to another for tax filings usually requires filing a formal request with the IRS and making adjustments to align prior-year balances. This is not something to undertake casually, but it can be appropriate when your business has grown or changed.

Pros and Cons From a Practical Standpoint

Cash basis:

• Pros. Simpler to maintain, closely tied to bank balances, easier for owner-operators to understand at a glance.
• Cons. Can obscure trends in receivables or payables; may make some periods look better or worse than underlying activity would suggest.

Accrual basis:

• Pros. Provides a clearer view of profitability for a given period; shows what is owed to you and what you owe others; supports more robust budgeting and analysis.
• Cons. More complex to implement; requires tracking receivables and payables; can feel less intuitive if you focus primarily on cash.

The best choice often depends on your size, complexity, and how much you rely on financial statements for planning rather than just compliance.

Choosing and Maintaining a Method

Once you pick a method for tax purposes, consistency matters. Regularly switching back and forth would make year-to-year comparisons and compliance difficult. That said, your internal management reports can incorporate elements of both.

For example:

• You might use accrual accounting for internal income statements to understand performance.
• You might still track and monitor a separate cash-flow report to inform immediate funding decisions.

Modern accounting systems can support both views from the same underlying data, as long as transactions are recorded with enough detail.

Aligning Method With How You Make Decisions

The real question is less "Which method is technically best?" and more "Which method produces information that helps you run the business?"

If your main focus is on keeping properties leased, paying bills on time, and avoiding surprises in the bank account, cash basis may be fully adequate in the early stages. As you add properties, take on longer-term projects, or talk to lenders or investors, accrual-based statements may become more useful for telling your story.

In either case, discussing your current and future plans with your CPA can help you choose a method that fits both operational needs and tax requirements, rather than defaulting into one simply because it was selected at startup and never revisited. For more on choosing the right accounting method and real estate bookkeeping, see our guides.