New York landlords can deduct all rental property expenses, including property taxes, mortgage interest, repairs, depreciation, and property management fees, without the $10,000 SALT cap that limits homeowners. These deductions are reported on Schedule E and treated as business expenses, not personal deductions. A $275,000 rental property generates roughly $10,000 in annual depreciation alone, plus unlimited property tax deductions that significantly reduce taxable rental income.
You own a Brooklyn rental property generating $36,000 annually in rent. You pay $8,500 in property taxes, $12,000 in mortgage interest, and $3,200 in repairs. Without understanding landlord tax deductions, you'd think you're taxed on the full $36,000. In reality, after claiming all eligible deductions including depreciation, your taxable rental income might drop to $7,000, saving you thousands in federal and New York State taxes.
New York landlords face some of the highest property taxes nationwide, averaging 1.38% of home value statewide and reaching $15,000-$25,000 annually for NYC properties. The good news: rental property owners aren't subject to the same limitations as homeowners. While someone living in their primary residence hits the $10,000 SALT deduction cap, landlords write off every dollar of property tax as a business expense.
Here's what you need to know: which expenses qualify for deductions, how depreciation works for New York rental properties, the difference between repairs and improvements, NYC-specific tax considerations, and how to document everything properly to withstand an IRS audit.
New York rental property deductions operate under federal tax law but with critical state-specific considerations. The biggest advantage: rental expenses aren't subject to the $10,000 state and local tax (SALT) deduction limit created by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. Homeowners living in their primary residence can only deduct up to $10,000 in combined state income taxes, local income taxes, and property taxes on their federal return. Landlords bypass this entirely because rental property taxes are classified as business expenses on Schedule E.
This distinction matters enormously in New York where property taxes routinely exceed $10,000. A Manhattan landlord paying $18,000 in annual property taxes deducts the full amount against rental income. A homeowner in the same building pays the same $18,000 but can only deduct $10,000 on their federal return. That $8,000 difference represents $1,760 to $2,960 in additional federal tax savings depending on your tax bracket.
New York City adds another layer: NYC landlords pay city income tax on rental income ranging from 3.078% to 3.876% based on total income. However, this city income tax becomes deductible as a state and local tax on your federal return. This creates a tax deduction that partially offsets the cost of the NYC income tax itself, a benefit specific to NYC rental property owners.
New York State also doesn't conform to some federal bonus depreciation rules. While federal tax law allows bonus depreciation on certain property improvements, New York requires you to add back these federal deductions and follow state-specific depreciation schedules. This means your federal and state tax returns will show different depreciation amounts, requiring careful tracking and potentially professional tax preparation services for multi-state compliance.
Depreciation is the single most valuable deduction for rental property owners, allowing you to recover the cost of your property over 27.5 years even while the property appreciates in market value. The IRS recognizes that buildings deteriorate over time, permitting you to deduct 3.636% of the property's cost basis annually. On a $275,000 rental property (excluding land value), that's $10,000 in annual depreciation deductions.
Calculating your depreciation basis starts with your purchase price plus qualified closing costs and immediate improvements, then subtracts the land value. If you bought a Brooklyn property for $500,000 with land valued at $150,000, your depreciable basis is $350,000. Divide that by 27.5 years and you get $12,727 in annual depreciation. This deduction appears on your tax return every year for 27.5 years, reducing taxable income even if your property remains fully rented and profitable.
The depreciation clock starts when you place the property in service for rental use, not when you buy it. If you purchase a property in March but don't list it for rent until July, depreciation begins in July. The first and last years use a mid-month convention, meaning you only deduct a partial year based on which month you started renting.
Major improvements get their own depreciation schedules. A new roof, HVAC system, or structural addition depreciates over 27.5 years starting when completed. However, certain components depreciate faster: appliances (5 years), carpeting (5 years), and furniture (7 years). Smart landlords use cost segregation studies to identify building components eligible for accelerated depreciation, pulling forward deductions from the 27.5-year schedule to 5, 7, or 15-year schedules.
One critical consideration: depreciation recapture. When you sell the property, the IRS taxes all depreciation you claimed at a maximum 25% rate, even if your ordinary income tax rate is lower. This doesn't eliminate the benefit, deferring taxes for years while taking annual deductions still provides significant cash flow advantages, but you need to plan for the eventual recapture tax liability.
New York landlords can deduct all ordinary and necessary expenses for producing rental income. The key test: is the expense directly related to your rental activity? If yes, it's likely deductible. Here are the major categories that apply to most New York rental property owners.
Property taxes are fully deductible without limit. Unlike homeowners capped at $10,000, rental property owners deduct every dollar paid to New York State, NYC, or local municipalities. For a property with $15,000 in annual property taxes, that's a deduction worth $3,300 to $5,550 in federal tax savings alone depending on your bracket. You must actually pay the taxes to deduct them, if your lender holds taxes in escrow, you deduct what the lender paid to the taxing authority, not what you paid into escrow.
Mortgage interest remains one of the largest deductions for leveraged properties. If you have a $400,000 mortgage at 6.5%, you'll pay roughly $26,000 in interest during the first year. Every dollar is deductible against rental income. This applies to mortgages used to purchase, construct, or improve the rental property. Interest on home equity loans or lines of credit qualifies only if you use the funds for rental property purposes, document how loan proceeds were spent.
Repairs and maintenance are immediately deductible in the year paid. This includes fixing leaks, repainting, replacing broken appliances, patching holes, cleaning, and general upkeep that keeps the property in good operating condition. The IRS distinguishes repairs (restoring to original condition) from improvements (adding value or extending useful life). Repairs are expensed immediately; improvements must be depreciated. Replace a broken window: repair. Replace all windows with energy-efficient models: improvement.
Property management fees are fully deductible whether you hire a company or pay an individual. If you pay 8-10% of collected rent to a management company handling tenant screening, rent collection, and maintenance coordination, those fees reduce your taxable income dollar-for-dollar. Professional bookkeeping services that track rental income and expenses also qualify as deductible management costs.
Insurance premiums for landlord policies, liability coverage, and loss-of-rent insurance are all deductible. This includes the additional cost of landlord coverage over standard homeowner insurance. If you pay $2,400 annually for comprehensive landlord insurance, that entire amount reduces your taxable rental income.
Utilities you pay on behalf of tenants, water, sewer, trash, gas, electric, are deductible. If your lease requires the landlord to cover certain utilities, track and deduct these costs. Even utilities for common areas in multi-unit buildings qualify. Keep documentation showing which utilities you pay versus which tenants pay directly.
New York City landlords navigate tax requirements that don't apply elsewhere in the state. Understanding these NYC-specific considerations prevents costly mistakes and ensures you claim all available deductions.
NYC imposes a city income tax on rental income separate from New York State income tax. The rate ranges from 3.078% to 3.876% depending on your total income, and it applies to rental income generated from NYC properties. This isn't an additional property tax, it's an income tax on the rental profits. However, this city income tax is deductible on your federal return as part of your state and local tax deduction, offsetting some of the cost.
Property tax calculations work differently in NYC compared to upstate. NYC assesses residential rental properties at percentages of market value depending on classification. Class 1 properties (one to three family homes) are assessed at 6% of market value, while Class 2 (larger residential buildings) are assessed at 45% of market value. The tax rate then applies to these assessed values. A $1 million Brooklyn brownhouse might show an assessed value of only $60,000, resulting in property taxes around $12,000-$15,000 depending on the neighborhood.
Short-term rentals in NYC face special rules. Properties rented for under 30 days must comply with the Multiple Dwelling Law and require specific permits. If you rent for less than 90 days at a time, you must collect 4% New York State sales tax on the rental. The sales tax you collect and remit reduces your rental income for tax purposes, you're not taxed on money you simply pass through to the state.
Several NYC tax incentive programs provide property tax exemptions or abatements for qualifying buildings. Section 421-a offers partial exemptions for new multifamily construction with exemption periods of 13-28 years. The J-51 program provides tax benefits for buildings undergoing renovations. The Affordable Housing from Commercial Conversion (AHCC) program offers substantial discounts for commercial-to-residential conversions including affordable units. These programs require ongoing compliance and timely renewal applications, missing a deadline can trigger immediate tax increases of $10,000-$50,000+ for larger buildings.
The distinction between repairs and improvements determines whether you deduct costs immediately or depreciate them over 27.5 years. The IRS applies three tests: does the work adapt the property to a new use, restore it to like-new condition, or materially add to its value? If any answer is yes, it's likely an improvement requiring depreciation rather than immediate expensing.
Repairs keep your property in ordinary operating condition without adding substantial value. Patching a roof leak is a repair. Replacing the entire roof is an improvement. Repainting an apartment after a tenant moves out is a repair. Painting exterior brick for the first time in 30 years might be an improvement. Fixing a broken boiler is a repair. Installing a brand new HVAC system is an improvement.
The IRS provides safe harbor rules for routine maintenance. If you expect to perform the activity more than once during your ownership (like repainting every few years), it's maintenance rather than an improvement. Regular tasks that keep property in ordinarily efficient operating condition qualify as repairs even if they involve substantial work.
Common repairs that New York landlords can expense immediately include fixing leaks, replacing broken tiles, repairing plumbing, electrical troubleshooting, plastering, repainting walls, replacing broken appliances with similar models, fixing gutters, patching concrete, and pest control. Document these with invoices showing the work performed and why it was necessary.
Common improvements requiring depreciation include room additions, finishing a basement, installing new kitchen cabinets (versus repairing existing ones), replacing all windows throughout the building, new roof installation, new HVAC systems, structural modifications, adding parking spaces, and installing a new bathroom. These costs get added to your property's basis and depreciated over 27.5 years starting when the improvement is placed in service.
The safe harbor for small taxpayers allows immediate expensing of improvements up to $10,000 per property per year if your average annual gross receipts are $10 million or less. Most small landlords qualify. This means you can replace a $8,000 water heater and deduct the full cost immediately rather than depreciating it, as long as you elect the safe harbor on your tax return. Maintaining detailed records of repair versus improvement decisions protects you during audits.
Rental real estate losses can offset other income, but strict limitations apply based on your income level and participation in the rental activity. Understanding these rules determines whether rental losses provide immediate tax benefits or must be carried forward to future years.
Active participation allows up to $25,000 in rental losses to offset ordinary income if your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is $100,000 or less. Active participation means you make management decisions, approving tenants, setting rent terms, approving repairs, even if you hire a property manager to execute these decisions. You must own at least 10% of the property to qualify.
The $25,000 allowance phases out between $100,000 and $150,000 in MAGI. For every $2 of income above $100,000, you lose $1 of the special allowance. At $150,000 MAGI or higher, the special allowance disappears entirely and passive loss rules apply. This means a landlord with $120,000 in MAGI can only deduct $15,000 in rental losses against ordinary income ($25,000 minus the $10,000 phase-out).
Real estate professionals bypass passive loss limitations entirely. If you work 750+ hours annually in real estate activities and more than half your working time involves real estate, you qualify as a real estate professional. This allows unlimited deduction of rental losses against any income. The catch: you must materially participate in each rental property individually, spending 500+ hours per property or meeting one of several alternative tests.
Passive losses that can't be deducted immediately carry forward indefinitely. They're suspended until you have passive income to offset them or until you dispose of the property in a taxable transaction. When you sell, all suspended losses become deductible, potentially offsetting the gain on sale. This creates tax planning opportunities, rental losses that seemed wasted actually reduce your tax bill years later.
Documentation determines whether your deductions survive an IRS audit. The standard is "adequate records", enough detail to prove the expense was ordinary, necessary, and directly related to your rental activity. Generic categories like "miscellaneous repairs" without supporting documentation get disallowed during audits.
Keep every invoice and receipt for rental property expenses. The document should show the date, payee, amount, and description of what was purchased or the service performed. "ABC Plumbing - $450" isn't enough. You need "ABC Plumbing - Repaired leaking kitchen faucet, replaced supply lines - $450." This level of detail distinguishes deductible repairs from capital improvements and proves the expense relates to the rental property.
Maintain a separate bank account for each rental property or portfolio. Commingling personal and rental funds creates accounting nightmares and raises red flags during audits. Deposit all rental income into the rental account and pay all rental expenses from it. This creates a clear paper trail showing income received and expenses paid. Many landlords use property management software or accounting platforms that automatically categorize transactions and generate reports for tax preparation.
Document mileage for rental property activities. Trips to the property for showings, inspections, repairs, or meeting contractors are deductible at the standard mileage rate ($0.67 per mile for 2025). Keep a mileage log showing date, destination, purpose, and miles driven. Smartphone apps can automate this tracking using GPS, making it easier to claim legitimate deductions without manual logbooks.
Retain all tax returns and supporting documentation for at least three years from the filing date, the standard IRS audit period. However, keep depreciation schedules and property purchase documents until three years after you sell the property. If you underreported income by more than 25%, the audit period extends to six years. For suspected fraud, there's no statute of limitations. The safest approach: keep rental property tax records for seven years and purchase/improvement records indefinitely.
Photograph properties before and after repairs to document the work performed. If the IRS questions whether a $15,000 expense was a repair or improvement, photos showing you replaced damaged elements with similar quality materials support the repair classification. Photos also document property condition when tenants move in and out, protecting against disputes over security deposit deductions that affect your taxable income.
Strategic tax planning helps New York landlords minimize tax liability legally and maximize cash flow. These planning opportunities require advance preparation rather than last-minute year-end scrambling.
Timing expenses provides immediate deductions when needed most. If you expect higher income this year than next, accelerate deductible expenses into the current year, schedule repairs in December rather than January, prepay insurance if allowed, or purchase supplies before year-end. Conversely, if you expect higher income next year, delay discretionary expenses to maximize deductions against higher-bracket income.
Cost segregation studies identify building components that depreciate faster than 27.5 years. A qualified engineer analyzes your property and reclassifies items like lighting, flooring, cabinetry, and site improvements to 5, 7, or 15-year schedules. On a $500,000 property, cost segregation might identify $100,000-$150,000 in accelerated depreciation, creating $20,000-$40,000 in additional first-year deductions. The upfront cost ($5,000-$15,000 for most properties) generates returns of 300-500% through accelerated deductions.
1031 exchanges defer capital gains taxes when selling rental properties. By reinvesting proceeds into replacement property within specific timeframes, you defer all federal and state capital gains taxes plus depreciation recapture. This allows your equity to compound tax-free across multiple property transactions. New York landlords who've owned properties for decades often have $200,000-$500,000+ in deferred gains that would trigger $50,000-$150,000 in taxes without a 1031 exchange.
Entity structuring affects liability protection and tax treatment. Many landlords hold properties in LLCs for liability protection. Single-member LLCs are disregarded for tax purposes, rental income still reports on your personal return via Schedule E. Multi-member LLCs or partnerships file separate returns (Form 1065) but income still flows through to owners. S-corporations rarely make sense for rental properties due to passive income limitations. Understanding entity structures and their tax implications prevents costly mistakes.
Hiring family members creates legitimate deductions while keeping income in the family. Pay your teenager to clean vacant units, handle yard work, or manage social media marketing for your rentals. As long as payments are reasonable for services actually performed, you deduct the wages while they report the income at their lower tax rate. This works for spouses and adult children too, pay your spouse to manage bookkeeping, and you deduct the management fee while they report it as self-employment income.
Yes, but you deduct what your lender actually paid to the tax authority, not what you paid into escrow. Your lender sends Form 1098 showing property taxes paid on your behalf. If you paid $15,000 into escrow but the lender only paid $14,000 to the county (because they hold reserves), you deduct $14,000. The timing difference between paying into escrow and the lender remitting taxes means your deduction might lag your cash payments by a few months.
Consistent losses trigger IRS scrutiny under "hobby loss" rules. The IRS questions whether you're truly operating for profit or just enjoying tax deductions on personal property. To prove profit motive, demonstrate business-like operations: maintain separate accounts, keep detailed records, adjust rent to market rates, actively market vacancies, and make property improvements. If the IRS reclassifies your activity as a hobby, you lose all deductions. Most legitimate rental properties show paper losses in early years due to depreciation, then shift to profits as appreciation builds equity.
Allocate expenses based on square footage or number of rooms. If you rent 40% of your property, you deduct 40% of property taxes, insurance, utilities, and maintenance. Depreciation applies only to the rental portion, calculate depreciation basis by excluding both land value and the personal-use portion. Keep meticulous records showing which expenses are shared (roof, furnace) versus exclusive to the rental unit (appliances, interior repairs). Direct expenses for the rental unit are 100% deductible regardless of allocation percentages.
Yes, if the primary purpose is rental property management. Deduct airfare, hotels, car rentals, and meals (50% for meals) for trips to inspect properties, meet contractors, show units, or handle tenant issues. The trip must be primarily business, spending more than 50% of the time on rental activities. Document the business purpose, meetings attended, properties visited, and time spent on rental activities versus personal time. If you combine business with vacation, allocate expenses proportionally between deductible business days and non-deductible personal days.
Appliances are depreciable over 5 years, not immediately deductible. When you buy a refrigerator, stove, or dishwasher for a rental unit, capitalize the cost and depreciate it over 5 years at 20% annually (using straight-line method). This applies whether the appliance is installed in a new property or replaces a broken one. However, if the appliance cost plus other improvements for that property are under $10,000 for the year, you might elect the safe harbor for small taxpayers and expense it immediately.
Yes, but strict rules apply. The space must be used regularly and exclusively for your rental activity, not a corner of your living room where you also watch TV. Calculate the percentage of your home used for the office (square footage method), then deduct that percentage of mortgage interest or rent, utilities, insurance, and depreciation. If your home office is 150 square feet in a 1,500-square-foot home (10%), and your home expenses total $24,000 annually, you deduct $2,400. Alternatively, use the simplified method: $5 per square foot up to 300 square feet ($1,500 maximum deduction).
Your depreciation basis is the lower of (1) adjusted basis on conversion date or (2) fair market value on conversion date. If you bought your home for $300,000 and it's worth $450,000 when you convert to rental, you depreciate $300,000 (minus land). If it's worth $250,000 at conversion, you depreciate $250,000 (minus land). This prevents deducting appreciation that occurred during personal use. Keep detailed records of property condition and value at conversion. You can still qualify for the $250,000/$500,000 home sale exclusion if you sell within 3 years of moving out and meet ownership/use tests.
Madras Accountancy specializes in rental property tax preparation for landlords with New York properties. We handle Schedule E preparation, depreciation calculations including cost segregation analysis, repair versus improvement classifications, multi-state tax filings for landlords with properties outside New York, and year-round bookkeeping to track income and expenses. Our team has prepared tax returns for real estate investors since 2015, managing the complexity of federal, New York State, and NYC tax requirements while maximizing legitimate deductions and maintaining audit-proof documentation.
New York landlords have access to substantial tax deductions that homeowners can't claim, particularly the unlimited deduction for property taxes and the powerful 27.5-year depreciation schedule. The key to maximizing these benefits lies in understanding what qualifies, maintaining excellent records, and planning expenses strategically throughout the year.
The immediate action items: separate your rental property finances from personal accounts, implement a system for tracking all income and expenses with proper documentation, calculate your depreciation basis correctly and ensure you're claiming it annually, distinguish repairs from improvements to maximize immediate deductions, and consider whether cost segregation makes sense for larger properties.
For landlords managing multiple New York properties or those with complex situations involving mixed-use properties, out-of-state holdings, or entity structures, professional accounting support ensures you don't leave money on the table. Madras Accountancy has provided comprehensive tax preparation and bookkeeping services for real estate investors since 2015, helping landlords navigate New York's complex tax environment while maximizing legitimate deductions and maintaining IRS compliance.
.png)
January 13, 2026
The IRS treats repairs as immediately deductible expenses that restore property to its original condition, while capital improvements must be capitalized and depreciated over 27.5-39 years.
January 13, 2026
An IRS 1031 exchange (named for Internal Revenue Code Section 1031) allows real estate investors to defer capital gains taxes when selling investment property by reinvesting proceeds into like-kind replacement property.
